How the Custom Ringtone Industry Paved the Way for the App Store — and Then Vanished
Before the iPhone, Venmo, or Spotify, there were ringtones. You might remember them fondly as those lo-fidelity sounds we used to communicate our highly refined music tastes every time someone called our cell. But ringtones were so much more than that. A billion-dollar industry silenced seemingly overnight, ringtones laid the foundations of modern mobile consumer technology and set the stage for the app store and mobile commerce as we know it today. And they are proof that even silly-seeming products can have an impact long after their memory fades away.
The Original Kindle Was Crazy
What the design of the first popular e-book reader can teach us about innovation
The rise of the ringtone
The first mobile phone call was not made by a silk-shirted Miami cocaine dealer in the ’80s, but by a driver in St. Louis in 1946 from a heavyweight wireless system installed in an automobile. It took another 40 years to make mobile phones portable, reliable, and affordable enough (relatively speaking) to offer to the mainstream consumer.
Even then, cellphones didn’t quite go “mainstream.” A common reaction in the 1980s was: Wow, that’s slick (it being the ’80s and all), quickly followed up with but, like, who really needs a portable phone? The president… maybe? At the time, it was hard for ordinary people to imagine having to be reachable at any minute of the day.
It wasn’t until the ’90s that owning a cellphone became relatively commonplace. But then another problem reared its head. In the early part of the decade, phones came with preset, annoying, monophonic ringtones. Never ones to miss an opportunity to spend R&D dollars on minor inconveniences, the telcos manufactured a feature that allowed users to input custom ringtones. The Digital Minimo D319, released in 1996, was a Japanese-made device on which users could program custom ringtones by entering combinations of boops and beeps associated with keys on the number pad.
A book that taught users to recreate popular songs sold 3.5 million copies in its first year.
Then, in 1998, a Finnish engineer tired of Nokia’s preset monotone interfering with his weekday hangovers (no joke) found a way to transfer audio files directly to his phone through text message and the ringtone revolution began in earnest. By 2002, 30% of all SMS traffic were requests for downloadable ringtones.
The rise of the custom ringtone, like many innovations, happened gradually, then all at once.
The ingredients were mostly in place by the mid-90s: Network operators hungry to make back their deep infrastructure investments and diversify their revenue streams, devices manufactured to make sound with the capacity to send and receive digitized data, and a proof of concept — customizable ringtones enabled by number pads in Asia and text messaging in Europe that proved demand.
Consumers jumped on custom ringtones because they represented the first mainstream way of getting portable music, on demand. No store, no CDs, no desktops. That was revolutionary — imagine the possibilities! People could define themselves in a unique way. Ringtones became an audio fashion accessory that users, young ones in particular, loved.
The only problem was, selling custom ringtones constituted explicit copyright infringement.
But two things happened in the late ’90s: 1) the rise of music piracy and 2) the development of digital micropayment technology. The former sunk music publishing revenues as CD sales plummeted; the latter created centralized micropayments platforms that could effectively collect royalties to be paid to music publishers in a way the web could not.
Custom ringtones showed technologists the power of frictionless payment and frictionless payment-enabled software to eat the world.
When music publishers and labels saw the potential for ringtones to reverse declining sales revenues, they entered into royalty agreements with telecoms and ringtone providers.
And so the stage was set. We blasted into the new millennium frantically searching our pockets for the 8-bit renditions of Smash Mouth and Shaggy that emanated from them. By the early 2000s, all the major record labels partnered with mobile operators to distribute and monetize the ringtone. At the time, observers proclaimed the ringtone to be the new single, and hailed the trend as “an industry shift no less important than the shift from the radio to the internet.”
Although that view didn’t age well, you can’t blame industry analysts for espousing it. The custom ringtone industry in the United States grew from $68 million in 2003 to $600 million in 2006. So many ringtones were sold — an estimated 520 million ringtones between 2001 and 2007 — that the Recording Industry Association of America instituted ringtone charts and awards associated with them. Lil Wayne’s “Lollipop,” for instance, went platinum five times.
Ringtones seeped into popular culture. Instead of music influencing ringtones, ringtones began to influence music. A wave of chart-topping rappers, including Soulja Boy, T-Pain, and J-Kwon made music designed to sound good as polyphonic ringtones. Ringtones became a form of marketing, a popular way for record labels to promote artists and albums, and served as cultural currency, offered as marketing incentives tied to a variety of promotional campaigns.
The world’s needle fit snugly with the ringtone’s polyphonic groove. But as quickly as they jingled into our pockets, consumers hung up on them.
Bye, bye, bye
Few of us foresaw the fall of the custom ringtone industry.
From a 2007 peak of $1.1 billion in global ringtone sales, the industry shrunk by 97% in the following decade. “Admittedly, it was a little sad,” recalled an executive with BMI, a music publisher. “In BMI’s early digital days, we made more money from ringtones than anything else; it accounted for more than half of our income stream. And now when you think about it, it’s basically zero.”
There are a few likely reasons for its decline:
- People stopped calling in favor of texting each other. Between 2008 and 2010, ringtone revenue declined 25% just as the average voice minutes used by 18–34-year-olds, the ringtone’s main customers, declined by roughly the same amount.
- The novelty of being able to customize phones wore off. As our phones evolved to offer web access, videos, games, and social networking 1.0, downloading and configuring ringtones was no longer particularly novel, especially with the rise of smartphones.
- The ubiquity of ringing devices forced us to develop cultural mores around our phones. With cellphones going fully mainstream, our culture evolved to solve for the cacophony of sounds they blasted in social settings — conference rooms, dinner tables, movie theatres — with a simple switch of the phone to vibrate.
- And my favorite theory: Crazy Frog killed it. In more eloquent words than my own:
The eventual ubiquity of a Swedish teenager’s imitation of a two-stroke moped engine applied to an ambiguously genitalled cartoon frog may finally have exhausted what little patience the consuming public had for overpriced novelty call alerts.
Given the rapid pace of innovation in mobile technology, it’s not surprising that a pop-culture meme like the ringtone fell prey to the digital world’s inexorable thirst for innovation. But that we almost completely erased its role in our digital evolution from our collective memory is less excusable.
Classic iPod Hackers Say There’s No Better Way to Listen to Music
Apple may have discontinued click-wheel iPods, but a community of iPod modders resurrects them for their sound and…
How ringtones shaped the modern world
In many ways, the custom ringtone made today’s digital age possible.
Ringtones introduced the concept of a digital store selling digital things made by a variety of creators. Today we call it an app store, a concept that didn’t exist 20 years ago but that has since become a fundamental building block of the digital world. When NPP, Japan’s pioneering telco, made ringtones available for their customers to purchase, they realized that 1) there’s very little marginal cost to “storing” digital products on their platform; 2) that it’s therefore in their interest to have as much content as humanly possible; and that 3) relying on ringtone providers alone constrains the amount of content they can offer.
With this in mind, NPP developed the world’s first app store as we conceive of it today: A platform that provided tools for developers to develop content, a system for micropayments and digital services, and an application environment that users valued and trusted enough to open their wallets. By opening the platform to developers, a whole ecosystem of digital products sprung up around the ringtone app stores, including prerecorded, humorous voicemail greetings (humorous being generously defined), custom wallpapers, ringback tones (remember when some people had songs play when you called them?), custom alarm sounds, and more.
The technological breakthroughs needed to bring a mobile app store to life, combined with ringtones’ popularity, cemented the app store’s role as critical infrastructure for the coming Digital Age. Custom ringtones showed technologists the power of frictionless payment and frictionless payment-enabled software to eat the world. It incentivized creators and developers to create while building consumer habits around digital purchasing that underpin today’s digital economy.
A defining feature of the digital world is the intricate link between all of our smart devices.
Custom ringtones were also most people’s first exposure to the magic of on-demand anything. Never before could the average consumer order something with the press of a button and get it immediately, regardless of where they were. This facilitated impulsive buying behavior (more on how that can be harnessed for good here) and stoked the public’s imagination with the possibilities of the new digital frontier.
With the establishment of on-demand digital stores and the trivial marginal costs of adding more content, consumers suddenly got mobile access to the long tail. Musicians without record deals could make their content available to a wide audience on demand, and make money off of it. For the first time, creators were able to skip pay-to-play channels like record stores or the radio to market their content.
Disintermediation is a peach of a narrative and Spotify, Soundcloud, and others gobbled it whole, without realizing that the custom ringtone germinated its seeds years earlier. The founder of Jamster, a German ringtone provider, said it clearly in 2006:
[Jamster] gives incentives for generating new content every day. The more content there is and the better I can sell it, the more the whole industry — and particularly the artists — will profit. I live from the long tail.
There was another conceptual role that ringtones played: connecting our phones to the rest of our electronics. When cellphones came out, they were perceived as a standalone piece of consumer hardware, much like a dishwasher or a radio might be. There wasn’t much linking the cellphone to other parts of the consumer electronics ecosystem, like the personal computer. You used one to make calls and the other to draw portraits of your turtle on Microsoft Paint.
But a defining feature of the digital world is the intricate link between all of our smart devices. It’s standard today to think of our phones as an extension of our computers or tablets: our data syncs automatically, we bookmark content on the phone to finish watching or reading on our computers, we share music libraries, respond to iMessages on our laptops, and so on. That was hard to imagine back when Gorbachev showed off his Nokia.
The custom ringtone showed both consumers and innovators the potential of redefining the phone as an extension of the computer, which was foundational for the development of the smartphone. First, one popular way to get ringtones (especially if you wanted them for free) was to download them onto your computer and then transfer them over to your phone, usually via Bluetooth. Second, to set up or change a ringtone, you had to dive into the phone’s operating system, a snorkeling adventure that, while not particularly complicated, involved the concept of nested folders, settings menus, and choice architecture. It exposed curious consumers to the shared operating principles common to both computers and phones.
There was another subplot that, inadvertently, drew a causal link between the ringtone and popularization of the smartphone. In the early 2000s, Apple had a plan to grow iTunes, its music app. On the heels of the global success of the iPod, they would partner with Motorola, the industry-leading manufacturer of the RAZR, to develop a cellphone with iTunes built-in. The idea got people very excited. But the result of that now unfathomable tryst was the Rokr E790 Candy Bar:
The phone turned out to be an abject user experience failure. It had a 100 song limit regardless of how much space you actually had left, and it was painfully slow at uploading songs from iTunes. Crucially, you couldn’t use it to buy ringtones or music remotely. Distributors had to slash its price within two months of launch. For Steve Jobs this was an eye-opening reminder: own your damn hardware. He took his intended strategy — develop a phone that had the iPod’s music playing capabilities as a way to capture a piece of the mobile segment while building a moat around Apple’s music business — and he built the iPhone, the vanguard of the smartphone revolution to come.
Ringtones’ lasting legacy
Ringtones remind me of childhood. Of the time I showed my mom how her device could bleat a monophonic rendition of Brahms’ “Hungarian Dances,” of how incredulous she seemed, how her eyes glimmered with wonder and curiosity. Of how she kept it as her ringtone for years to come.
I learned to download ringtones for free onto my parents’ phones and I remember how proud I felt as I would scroll through the recent downloads in waiting rooms, in bank lines, in backseats, my mom nearby worrying about whatever grown-ups worried about. I’d play my new acquisitions on her phone — Backstreet Boys, System of a Down, Black Eyed Peas — just loud enough for others to hear but quiet enough to avoid her scolding.
Yes, it’s great we aren’t living in an endless menagerie of electronic sounds competing with each other for attention. But in some ways it’s sad they’ve all but disappeared from our lives: Little packages of sound like parcels of identity sent from pockets and handbags, announcing someone else needing you, or thinking of you, or inviting you to something.
So I guess it is some consolation that we chose to walk through the doors that the world of ringtones opened for us and live today in the possibilities it presented.